MAN WHO SHOT NEIGHBOR TO PAY $30,000 SETTLEMENT By Louie Estrada December 7, 1996 A Leesburg man yesterday agreed to pay $30,000 to settle a $3.75 million wrongful-death suit filed after he was. He was then arrested again 12 days later and charged with a double homicide. In a case that some legal specialists said pushes the boundaries of self-defense, a Loudoun County jury found Robert G. Lorenz, 54, not guilty of murder or manslaughter in the shooting death of Duren Wayne Eldridge, 31. You know, till this day I have no idea why that man came over here. A defense psychologist testified Lorenz was so gripped by fear he could not Lorenz also will drop his $4 million counterclaim against the Eldridge estate. Its acompilation of older seasons but totally worth the cost if you are a true crime addict. The 26-year-old had just rented a home on Beattie Street in St. Joseph, Missouri. The shooting was the culmination of months of tension between the quiet Lorenz, who works for the Federal Emergency Management Agency, and the raucous family renting the house across the street in suburban Washington. (LogOut/ a Lorenz vehicle, neighbors said. The shooting culminated months of bad blood between the quiet, fastidious But someone close by has very different ideas. ride his skateboard in front of Lorenz's house to aggravate the older man, and A mans dream comes true when he buys his parents' house and moves his family into it, only to discover that his neighbor on the other side of the fence holds a decades long grudge against him that wont be resolved until one of them lies dead. Lorenz sought to recover costs for medical and legal bills that stemmed from the incident. Keep supporting great journalism by turning off your ad blocker. Keep supporting great journalism by turning off your ad blocker. Two women with a shared wall between their townhouses become increasingly volatile with each other as their once good relationship disintegrates. Robert Lorenz, 54, had said he shot Duren Wayne Eldridge on April 9 when the 31-year-old Eldridge came to his door and began threatening him. Differences over how to enjoy life in a rural neighborhood quickly escalate into a feud that comes to a bloody end on the road where it began. He told the cops that he shot them because he felt threatened. The jury heard a one-sided view of a neighbor she said was helpful and On the day the Eldridges moved in, their dogs relieved themselves on 20 Jun. "Fear Thy Neighbor" Kill-De-Sac (TV Episode 2015) - IMDb In Virginia and most other states, the law allows people to use deadly force only if they have a reasonable belief that they are in danger of imminent bodily harm or death. report that a teen-ager visiting Eldridge's household had damaged Lorenz's -Kill-De-Sac, Fear Thy Neighbor (S2, E8) Date: April 9, 1995 Victim: Duren Eldridge, 31, truck driver Offender: Robert 'Bob' Lorenz, 54, military veteran, federal employee Location: Leesburg, Virginia "I feel strongly against what happened," Lorenz said. Lorenz said he does not remember firing the fatal shot to Eldridge's chest. Robert Lorenz | MILITARY JUSTICE FOR ALL Fear Thy Neighbor (2014-2022) Full Cast & Crew See agents for this cast & crew on IMDbPro Series Directed by Series Writing Credits Series Cast Series Produced by Series Music by Series Cinematography by Series Film Editing by Series Casting By Series Production Design by Series Art Direction by Series Set Decoration by Series Costume Design by Neighbors take sides after someone decides to build a dream home on their quiet street; longtime friends turn into hardcore enemies, and death is right around the corner. According to testimony in the trial, Duren Eldridge started the late-afternoon argument by shouting obscenities at Lorenz and then banged on Lorenz's front door and challenged him to a fight. -Kill-De-Sac, Fear Thy Neighbor (S2, E8), Date: April 9,1995 A man who is meticulous about his lawn bickers with a new neighbor who doesn't have the same priorities; the feud between the two men escalates, ultimately ending in an episode of shocking violence. Food fights, physical altercations, and mutual vandalism will finally come to a bloody climax. (LogOut/ Shaffer said his client cannot comment because the Eldridge family has ``I speak for the Lorenz family when I say their hearts go out to the -Kill-De-Sac, Fear Thy Neighbor (S2, E8) Date: April 9, 1995 Victim: Duren Eldridge, 31, truck driver Offender: Robert 'Bob' Lorenz, 54, military veteran, federal employee Location: Leesburg, Virginia Season 7 of the main series began on February 26, 2021, with the episode "Im Not Moving". stories from both families, eyewitnesses and neighbors in the Leesburg Last month, she moved out of the neighborhood. No sympathy for your evil grandfather. Red Flags Raised Over Mysterious Disappearances, Sexual Assaults | Hollie McKay (January 6,2021), Truth will come to lightAt length the truth will out. WilliamShakespeare, Report of the Fort Hood Independent Review Committee (November 6,2020), Donny Walker Show: Update on Fort Hood Investigations, Federal Government Cold Case Policy, and The Kamisha Block Bill (October 6,2020), Speier, Mullin Introduce Bipartisan I Am Vanessa Guilln Act to Transform the Militarys Response to Sexual Violence & Missing Servicemembers (September 16,2020), Research Reveals Pattern of Violence, Suspicious Deaths, Problematic Death Investigations, and Cover-up at Fort Hood in Texas (September 11,2020), Fort Hood Army Sgt. A couple moves into their dream home on the same street where theyve lived for years, only to find themselves engulfed in a wrenching conflict with their neighbor who believes hes the rightful owner of their property. -Red Picket Fences, Fear Thy Neighbor (S1, E2), Fear Thy Neighbor Premiered Red Picket Fences on Investigation Discovery: Richard Uffelman & 2 Children Executed The Phillips in Small Town Maine (April 21, 2014), In Miami, a young mother has no choice but to shut the door on her warring neighbors as a three-year feud over a patch of land and differing moral standards reaches a bloody and tragic conclusion. Weigle was hit four times in the chest, and Keller escaped injury. May God have Mercy on your souls All of you. When the cops arrived, they found 45-year-old DePaul and 42-year-old Dempsey lying facedown in a breezeway; they had both been shot in the head. S8 E5 - Other People's Property. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Fear Thy Neighbor Premiered Kill-De-Sac on Investigation Discovery: Robert Lorenz Shoots Duren Eldridge, Claims Self-Defense, Acquitted of Murder (June 1,2015), Jury Acquits Virginia Man Who Killed Neighbor, Fastidious Homeowner Acquitted of Murdering Raucous Neighbor, Man Who Shot And Killed Angry Neighbor Acquitted, Loudon Slaying Acquittal Greeted with Accolades and Anger, Man Who Shot Neighbor to Pay $30,000 Settlement, Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (S2, E8), Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (website), Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (Amazon), Fear Thy Neighbor: 23 Veteran Cases Featured on Investigation Discovery. Download the ID Go app and binge away. It didnt take this long. Where's the malice?". Fear Thy Neighbor explores nightmares that are living right next door. It was premeditated murder! Rate Action Crime Drama When a freewheeling family moves from California to the buttoned down enclave of Leesburg, Virginia, they quickly get on the wrong side of their neighbour across the way. Prosecutors, who argued that the shooting was a premeditated act that followed months of bad blood, said Lorenz was never in danger and simply could have shut the door and called the police. 'Fear Thy Neighbor' Season 6 released on Investigation Discovery on August 1, 2019. was not a bully. Yeah lets see what you do in that situation. The jury could have convicted Lorenz of a lesser charge. Staff writers Victoria Benning and Peter Pae contributed to this report. Loudon Verdict Fits Community This week on Reasonable Doubt, the team takes on the Raul and Cathy Sarinana were sentenced to death for abusing Would love your thoughts, please comment. Victim:Duren Eldridge, 31, truck driver But when the relationship sours, tensions build up and bullets fly. Makes me SICK. LEESBURG, Va. (AP) _ A fastidious homeowner who shot a drunken neighbor in a dispute over teen-age skateboarders ripping up his flower beds was acquitted of murder Thursday after claiming self-defense. Lorenz said he fired a .380-caliber semiautomatic pistol only after calling police during the confrontation. It's one person that is confrontational without reason and one surreptitiously annoying person. The day of the shooting, Eldridge confronted Lorenz on the older mans porch, angry at Lorenz for calling police to report that a teen-ager visiting Eldridges household had damaged Lorenzs prized flower garden. Murder of Bob DePaul and August Dempsey by Kenneth Hoyle investigated He wasnt in the best of shape to fight my friend I say that becuase im his grandson His young military days were over by that point and he was basically handicapped bro. "He had no idea he was unarmed," said defense attorney Mark L. Shaffer. Lorenz, who had faced up to life in prison if convicted of murder, cried and hugged his family after the verdict. This not only traumatized the young kids seeing Duren stumbling across the street and dropping dead on his front porch, it affected his entire family and friends. Tensions boil over at a birthday party, where shots are fired and blood is spilled. "Mere words alone do not justify deadly force," Commonwealth's Attorney Robert D. Anderson told the jury during closing arguments. When he died, his blood-alcohol level was Having money to hire a skilled, manipulative attorney does not constitute innocenceIt only lends to the theory of privilege amongst a portion of society that literally Gets away with Murder and more. "It certainly is an unusual verdict," said Anne Coughlin, a University of Virginia visiting professor who specializes in criminal law. That testimony, along with the recording of a 911 call placed by Lorenz's wife, Laura, that captured parts of the argument, was the most compelling evidence, Shaffer said. A former police chief who owns most of the homes on his street gets into constant conflict with a young renter who doesn't respect his authority. Or purchase a subscription for unlimited access to real news you can count on. ", Canyon Country, Santa Clarita, California, "FREMANTLEMEDIA INTERNATIONAL ADDS EXCITING NEW CONTENT TO ITS CATALOGUE FOR MIPCOM 2014", "Investigation Discovery Unveils New Programming Slate Including 'The Perfect Murder' & 'Cell Block Psychic', "Investigation Discovery Reveals New Season of "Fear Thy Neighbor," Premiering Monday, April 13 at 10/9c", "Watch Fear Thy Neighbor Season 6 | Prime Video", https://www.amazon.com/Fear-Thy-Neighbor-Season-7/dp/B091GRXSSY, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Fear_Thy_Neighbor&oldid=1137431122. Preview: In North Carolina, a retired Vietnam veteran sells off a piece of his land to a young family. They can kill you with their hands.". Bob is/was and ALWAYS will be a a self-entitled MURDERER even in death. I live near Frankford. ``He fired a weapon. Danetta Henry was murdered by Alvin Dalton from Fresno, California. Although Lorenz was charged with first-degree murder, the jury could have convicted him of second-degree murder or manslaughter. A disabled fireman polices his neighbors, punishing them for violations ranging from loud music to off-leash dogs. Circuit Court. Location:Leesburg, Virginia Fear Thy Neighbor: 25 Veteran Cases Featured on InvestigationDiscovery, Fear Thy Neighbor Premiered Kill-De-Sac on Investigation Discovery: Robert Lorenz Shoots Duren Eldridge, Claims Self-Defense, Acquitted of Murder (June 1,2015), Jury Acquits Virginia Man Who Killed Neighbor, Fastidious Homeowner Acquitted of Murdering Raucous Neighbor, Man Who Shot And Killed Angry Neighbor Acquitted, Loudon Slaying Acquittal Greeted with Accolades and Anger, Man Who Shot Neighbor to Pay $30,000 Settlement, Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (S2, E8), Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (website), Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (Amazon), Fear Thy Neighbor: 23 Veteran Cases Featured on Investigation Discovery, Follow MILITARY JUSTICE FOR ALL on WordPress.com, Senate Armed Services Subcommittee on Personnel Hearings: Sexual Assault in the Military (March 24,2021), Fort Hoods Toxic Culture? A family loves everything about its new home except the. Blizzard of Blood. I hated them both, two asshats constantly riling each other up, though it looked like Coone was the biggest ass hat. Conflict soon arises with the whole community over dogs, noise, and other disturbances that keep piling on and ratcheting up until a boiling point is reached, guns are drawn, and blood is spilled. Lorenz's attorney argued that he feared Eldridge was about to attack him. Shaffer said the Eldridge family has filed a $3.7 million lawsuit against Lorenz. Dylan Eason and Isaiah Churchwell were convicted of murdering Cynthia William "Patrick" Alexander remains in prison for murder. Loudon Slaying Acquittal Greeted with Accolades and Anger fear for his life or acted in anger. Editors note: With a cable subscription, you can download the free ID Go app and watch all of the Investigation Discovery programming at your convenience. believed he acted to save his life. Murder of Scott Robbins by James Dellavecchia examined on Fear Thy Neighbor A single mom and her four children find an ideal home in. Lorenz said he agreed to settle because the costs of the dispute were becoming overwhelming. "Why not close the door and lock it? Instead of the new start he was hoping for, a man's move to. coward and talked about fighting him over the police call, witnesses said. Brian Spinks Stabbed 60+ Times by Jealous Girlfriend; Kimethia Coleman Sentenced to Life in Prison, No Parole (January 17, 2010), Forensic Files Premiered 'Plastic Puzzle': Navy Veteran Kirk Hudson Struck & Killed in Hit-And-Run Accident in Kalamazoo, Michigan (June 1, 2005), Navy Veteran Christopher Ingraham Jr. Fatally Shot While Sleeping; Girlfriend Katrina Bridges Found Guilty, Sentenced to 47 Years (January 4, 2001). In the early hours of July 16, 2017, at approximately 2 am, Hoyle shot and killed his two neighbors. Prosecutors said that after Lorenz went back into his house and emerged with a .380-caliber semiautomatic handgun, he baited a retreating Eldridge, eventually shooting him once in the chest after a second brief round of yelling. "Most of us feel it was very unfortunate," said Comerford, 49. Especially with how hard it is to find good step dads today and this amazing one lost his life standing ground for a safe place for the kids? In a tight-knit community, a new family commits a slight against a community member causing all of their neighbors to turn against them and leading to an explosive conclusion. This one really got to me. Upset that Lorenz had called police about the skateboarders, Eldridge started the late-afternoon argument by shouting obscenities at Lorenz and then banged on the door and challenged him to a fight. Two neighboring bachelors start out as friends; harmless banter turns into threats which eventually ignite an escalating war; the violence ends with a murder which is so shocking and almost beyond belief. 2022. He deserves to pay something for Fear Thy Neighbor: Tony Coone vs. Bob Hayes : r/DiscoveryID - reddit Change). For those who prefer commercial free programming during your binge session, Prime Video has an ID channel: True Crime Files by Investigation Discovery available for $2.99 a month. Instead, prosecutors noted, Lorenz went back into his house after five minutes of arguing -- closing but not locking a glass storm door while Eldridge stood outside -- before emerging with his gun. He definitely has a mental problem and he is a coward. The men's feud leads to property damage, a backhoe attack, and ultimately, murder. Surveillance footage did show DePaul and Dempsey cross onto Hoyles property, but the pair were unarmed, and investigators concluded that they hadnt posed an immediate threat to Hoyle. "If someone threatens to kill you, it doesn't matter. So it was one dieing from being beat to death or one dieing by the gun.. One woman's picture-perfect island sanctuary reveals itself to be filled with dangers in this exciting page-turner