After French King Louis XVI was tried and executed on January 21, 1793, war between France and monarchal nations Great Britain and Spain was inevitable. Yeah. I dont get the sense from hearing that that theyre gonna actively oppose Marjorie Taylor. And thats one of the burdens of leadership as you have to set that cultural course in the right direction. Yeah. One of the things I fear about the right is the cultural course of the river that is being said. Dont say it. Articles from Britannica Encyclopedias for elementary and high school students. Sure. Oh, god. Both these revolutions had the similar cause, effects, and stages that resulted or started them. anything. And Im talking to one of the most lovely people whos, you know, upped your eyeballs and debris trying to dig peoples possessions out of this catastrophe. Right? The thesis of the book is really stated in the first sentence of the book, which is that there isnt any truly national, cultural, religious, social, political trend that is pulling us together more than its pushing us apart. Saying how wrong now. Show your support with Bulwark merchandise. They are like to use that an illustration. Oh, man. They were swimming along with the course quite merrily. The Haitian Revolution was the most radical. They take they take they take they keep taking rights away. Pyramid, the tip of the infotainment spear saying, Arizona is lost and the people just said, no, I refuse. Like, theres a part of the party that wanted Donald Trump. Right? And thats a classic example of how the old instincts meet the new coalition. Because people do talk about the idea of national war, civil war, and just like how tense things are all the time. First, I. think Fox is probably the most down the middle of any of them. And I think thats invariably true, but I also think this is how Charlie sometimes puts it. They just think one might be coming based on what theyre seeing around them. These countries shared the same idea of freedom and independence, the difference is they used different methods of accomplishing this goal. All the way back to twenty eighteen and twenty twenty and twenty twenty two that said, oh, maybe this doesnt work. So let me just hit you with a smattering of what we hear. And hes the Republican nominee. Thats right. Several men in uniform clap as another is presented with an award. And they said, well, we liked it because we voted and then we got a paper print out that showed exactly who we voted for to confirm And then that paper printout was what was actually scanned. Well, then I stand you know, more afraid. The others resulted in political changerather than social or economic change. The bastille was a jail where all the prisoners were being kept. I mean, of course, nobodys voted yet. There can be. They had the same reason to revolt as the colonist did, they both felt like they were being oppressed, overtaxed and felt like they were. They revolted in response to events happening in Europe. was such a textbook example of countless conversations Ive had since late twenty fifteen, which is one of the responses people have to some of the most outrageous rhetoric on the right whether it comes from Trump or it comes from Marjorie Taylor Green or Matt Gates, or you name it, is they laugh. They fought for their independence and release. And people can do it for a while. And Ive had the same conversation with folks who say, well, I go first to fox, and then I also look at CNN. About all of this rhetoric. I dont see so much national divorce rhetoric coming from the left. Lets and hes a rhino. Thats the key here is that. This war lasted for ten years, from 1765 to 1783. This whole voting system is ridiculous. Always what about. Three of their major results, In February 1861, a new government was on the horizon in the United States, known as the Confederate States of America. Within 50 years, the European empires in the Americas would shrink and new nations would spread across the whole of the Americas. Lastly, both parties got power in the end from whom they wanted to be free from. However, the Civil War was a not a complete representation of a second American Revolution. The British Empire won the Seven Years' War (17561763), but the victory was expensive, and it put the empire into debt. Two of the main revolutions were the French Revolution and the Latin American Revolution. And who has the power? What classes took power in South America, and how was this different from the class that took power in Saint Domingue? And, you know, one of the powers you wanna go back to our founding documents, for example, the statement that all men are created equal and endowed by their creator certain unalienable rights among them, life liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, was setting a cultural course for the United States that we were often contrary to, but had enormous power over the course of the next two centuries plus to where eventually we started to get more and more and more in conformity with that vision. Although, can I just ask, what every time somebody brings up the national divorce, I know in your book, you kinda lay out two scenarios, one where Texas secedes, one where California secedes, but, like, national divorce doesnt make any sense? So David, heres my notice about these comments. by. The Creole population led the revolutions initially. Mhmm. Lastly, both parties got power in the end from whom they wanted to be free from. And it was that power of the cultural river. American Revolution, also called United States War of Independence or American Revolutionary War, (177583), insurrection by which 13 of Great Britains North American colonies won political independence and went on to form the United States of America. By contrast, the British army was a reliable steady force of professionals. Can you imagine a United States of Latin America? The American Revolution hoped to achieve Independence . introduced? The American Revolution set the background for the modern nation state as well as molding the modern Army. Using the language of the Enlightenment, they initially tried to promote harmony between France's social classes and establish a constitutional monarchy with King Louis still on a throne. Well, yes. Absolutely not. From the beginning, sea power was vital in determining the course of the war, lending to British strategy a flexibility that helped compensate for the comparatively small numbers of troops sent to America and ultimately enabling the French to help bring about the final British surrender at Yorktown. So I wanna talk to all about one of the core causes. The leadership in both countries at the time of their revolutions was certainly repressive, especially in terms of taxation. Mhmm. And with them, one of the guys in there when hes saying, you hear him say, Id only trust them because I saw it with my own eyes. 4.6. If you're seeing this message, it means we're having trouble loading external resources on our website. Look, thats an unhealthy instinct in a democratic policy. King Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette lived in Versailles far from the other forms of government, abusing the country wealth. And this is happening not just in the sense of you and your neighbor being pushed apart. This is this is how things go. In the early nineteenth century, some Latin American revolutionaries wanted exactly that. Compare And Contrast The American Revolution Vs French Revolution. But guess what? So how much have we built sort of this cultural stream that is now so powerful that any given individual cant really stand in front of it anymore and say no more no more And however, here is where I will say that Im seeing some signs of hope. In other words, you dont have to defeat or suppress another person to live according to your core values. Almost had a civil war. But how interested are Americans really and breaking up? This document declared the sovereignty of the American states and listed the natural rights of mankind. JVL? There was a mixture of communities throughout the American colonies, there was loyalist communities, and there were revolutionary communities, and they were often in the same city, they were often in the same colony, in secession, there were parts of the south that didnt want to secede. For Britain, taxing their American colonies seemed like a great idea, but after such a long time of self-rule and near autonomy, the colonists in North America had ideas of their own. Now, why is that bad news? Its pretty much like in good faith But because theyre pouring Fox News and the daily wire and other right wing sources into their ears, they dont have that much context, and they do think that Fox is the most trustworthy, and its all the other people who are wrong, look, people are responsible for their own actions, responsible for things, but they Im most had been poisoned slowly by these institutions. In other words, the way that you deal with the dissent and debate in profound disagreements in what he calls like the danger or the violence of faction is not by trying to suppress factions. And the answer is the one you feed. The goals of both of these are different for a reason, because the French Revolution wanted a government and the American Revolution wanted to get away from their government. Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). Do you feel good about the fact that I said national divorce? pulls his name out of the app, a lot of those investigations will automatically disappear. Right? And, like, ten seconds later, like, and its those stupid Democrats that wont, you know, get on board with whatever. The American and French Revolution are not duplicates of each other, but they are very similar. You know, the mainstream media will call it out when the left messes up. Taxation without representation was when the government taxed the colonies without. Hence, in contrast to the American Revolution, the French . So Im gonna say something again, which is that this is another situation where I I listen to these people, and theyre telling you that they dont know where to go for the truth. In general, the American Revolution was more successful than the French revolution. Theyre not always accurate either. Right? only as a way they would ask what happened to Tucker is if Tucker started to question what was happening at Fox, Right? Everybody wants to break off here. The Declaration of Independence was basically announcing them as not the thirteen colonies but as the first thirteen states of the U.S. One is theres always a what about Yep. Ive never seen it like this. Everyone she talks to. So its been a a minority of it is now in which makes it far more powerful. The American revolution and the French Revolution are two major incidents happened in the 1700s, which had intense social impacts on both French and American societies. Although the Civil War and American Revolution shared many similarities, the Civil War differed in the fact that it was more of a confrontation of two opposing, In the first place, both the American and French Revolution had their causes that would change history. But now Im against it because we have to take care of our own people first. Fire the picture, who just called this right. So it was a better system than Id seen before. The American Revolution led to the creation of a democratic republic. I didnt think the bulk of Americans, there was this really great moment at the very beginning of the focused group about national divorce with the Trump voters, where her comments were brought up, and most of the Zoom room laughed. Although Great Britain, Spain, and France settled in the Americas, their colonies developed in almost completely different ways, like: The Spaniards colonized mainly in South and Central America for economic purposes, like to grow sugar, which lead its colonies to be mainly plantations; The Frenchs main goals in the Americas were to trade fur with the Native Americans and to find a route to the Pacific Ocean to trade with Asia; and the Britishers came here for two main purposes, one for economic matters and to avoid the religious conflict that was happening in England. However, over time divisions of opinion became apparent between federalists and anti-federalists. And I dont know enough about them to know if theyre trustworthy or not either. But we talked about leadership. Now, theres no real condemnation to it. I see this buildup of of, like, a different type of civil war, almost, where its, like, its not a civil war of fighting, its a civil war of works. I mean, the number of times youre just listening to the sweetest grandma. They have their own agenda, but the media in this country, thats who thats almost who elects the president. They continue to trust Fox. Then youll go to the daily wire. Many people in that group would say, what happened to Chris Russo? Divided We Fall: Americas Secession Threat and How to Restore Our Nation (by David French), https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/26/opinion/fox-news-lies-dominion.html, Learn more about your ad choices. However, there are crucial differences that led to their respective results and their . Others were unemployed persons from the urban slums. Whats the solution you get? Were like, well, in the beginning, I was for it. And then as soon as the topic veers into politics, then all of a sudden its like watching one of these old sitcoms where the cars driving and you see the transmission coming out in the road and the wheels are coming off, then youre thinking, wait. And now you can talk, but Im so bad about this. An MTG isnt the only high profile figure to raise the prospect of secession, national divorce and civil war over the past few years. Two revolutions, both taking place in the 18th Century, both world-changing. The American Revolution was principally caused by colonial opposition to British attempts to impose greater control over the colonies and to make them repay the crown for its defense of them during the French and Indian War (175463). They also wanted to create a new government but king Louis XVI wouldnt sign it off so the National Assembly got mad and they overthrew the bastille. French The majority of the people did not want the revolution (American, French, or Both?) The Enlightenment, which started in France and is associated with writers such as Rousseau and Voltaire, caused those under the thumb of monarchies to begin to recognize the inequality inherent in such systems. Okay. sooner rather than later, its getting very difficult to talk. Composed of seven states from the South, this new government looked to separate from a union that they felt was tipping in power towards those who wanted to threaten the rights of the South, especially slavery. Republican Party to take on Donald Trump. By the end of the second close read, you should be able to answer the following questions: At the end of the third close read, respond to the following questions: A painting shows a city on fire. The American, French, and Haitian Revolution all had the similar causes of a tyrannical government. Shes there to fire up the the far right wingers. Right. Everyone, and welcome to the Focus Group podcast. Thats right. But, like, we get out, man. Even with both Revolution developing years apart they had very similar desires and obstacles to face. And were having a great conversation and then she turns to me and she says, you know, they sent this tornado to punish the red states. And that is wrong. For a national divorce or a civil war. Theyre not going to talk about their own lives and theyre gonna continue to say the mainstream media lies, the mainstream media lies, the mainstream media lies. And and the question is is like, well, which one wins? I mean, if you ask them about Merrick Garland, like, talk about someone whos tanking with them. Marjorie Taylor Greene wants a national divorce. Compare and Contrast American and French Revolution. Number two, theres a minimization of whats negative about Trump or the Trumpist movement. A bloody, crowded battle scene shows Haitian revolutionaries fighting for their independence against European colonizers. What first sparked the American Revolution? Theyre passive participants and commentators about events that theyre not in control of that theyre not gonna exert their will over one way or the other. I used to respect you. Thats all the good news. In North America, colonists fought off the British. There are forces that are stretching us and pulling us. And they they do lean right, absolutely. That was populist and demagogenic and had all of these things that allowed Donald Trump to sort of get in there with his plurality and Yeah. And, like, sometimes people end up. Though they received no formal training, they were not so dependent on a book knowledge of military tactics as were many of the Americans. But before I do that since you brought it up, I wanna hit this set. they think they should take, and thats a compromise to them. During the French Revolution, there was a period known as the Reign of terror which was a period of extreme violence and brutality against people who did not support the French Revolution. Students complete an 11 item graphic organizer with 3 questions to compare and contrast the Revolutionary War and French Revolution. I mean, there were people who said, and I hear this all the time, or was like, look, as long as they got an r by their name, like, Im gonna wait for them. So it is scary to think about, like, I I dont hope for it and would never wish on it, but its scary and I think that is a possibility just with such polarized ideologies and people seeing that, you know, these things are possible. Because these are the people who sort of know better, but theres no leader or anybody else who is appealing to the good nature thats inside of them that you hear coming out and is pulling on those best instincts to say we have to resist this. But like for the most part, they were decent people who recognized, like, that Trump is bad. Is that a collapse in the faith of institutions? This is a group that dislikes Donald Trump, wants to move on to Ron DeSantis. And so you can be a majority. The French Revolution had the cause of starvation, and both the American and French Revolutions had the cause of unfair Taxes. This is never gonna happen. Divisions along racial, class, and ideological lines frequently led to violence. The great majority became efficient soldiers as a result of sound training and ferocious discipline. Dont trust mail in and then Fox calls for Arizona, and the whole right wing population or much of it was like, wait, we were told not to trust this process, and theres Fox going ahead and calling this red state for Biden that cant possibly be real. At least there are a a voice thats different and gives you another viewpoint. But youre right when we read them Marjorie Taylor Greens tweet, here is how they responded. Have no idea where to find the right answer. And how . That cannot be taken away by living as a red minority in a blue state or a blue minority in a red state. Okay. Its difficult to pin point which country chose the best method, but we compare some of the facts and take a deeper look as to what was transpiring in both of these Revolutions. This is the kind of group where you see the most change. But that everyone said they would not trust the FBI or any other institution who prosecuted Trump. You know, every dollar we have says, out of many one on it and, like, you know, if its built into our American infrastructure and we dont live off to it, but we still have like the best tools. PDF. If you missed it a couple weeks back, Margery Taylor Green tweeted, we need a national divorce. Canada: The influence of the American Revolution, Explore highlights of the Revolutionary War, which won 13 American colonies their political independence from Great Britain, Paul Reveres ride and the Battles of Lexington and Concord, The Siege of Boston and the Battle of Bunker Hill, The surrender at Saratoga and French involvement, Final campaigns in the South and the surrender of Cornwallis, The status of naval forces at the outbreak of war, French intervention and the decisive action at Virginia Capes, Causes and Effects of the American Revolution, https://www.britannica.com/event/American-Revolution, Econlib - Benefits of the American Revolution: An Exploration of Positive Externalities, Boston Tea Party Ships and Museum - American Revolution, American Battlefield Trust - American Revolution Timeline, Humanities LibreTexts - American Revolution, American Revolution - Children's Encyclopedia (Ages 8-11), American Revolution - Student Encyclopedia (Ages 11 and up), skirmishes between British regulars and American provincials on April 19, 1775. We are having this really great conversation. You know, get out the first and you wont be the last person to accuse me of polyamish thinking about people. The English Civil War was a war between the Parliamentarians and Royalists in England. Youre gonna be automatically dismissive. We know not to take them seriously. Even then theyd find ballots back to somebodys trunk, but it was a lot more difficult. I do not like them. This is a guy whos a slave owner. Both the Creoles and the church were alarmed by the social radicalism of the revolt and worried that it would end like the French and Haitian revolutions. Sort of laughing at the excesses and not taking it incredibly seriously. Good standing. My special favorite is one and you just heard some examples of this where theyre like, yes, things are so bad. So long as their politicians remain Republican compared to the Democratic Party, which is just not an for them, period end discussion, no further conversation necessary. Maybe its both. Im the toughest right winger in the room kind of thing. And so these people including the women in the group are like, well, I would vote for a woman, but unfortunately, I dont think other people would or I think world leaders wouldnt take them seriously because of how these other countries are. But if fifty five percent had voted to leave, Scotland might be independent as messy as that would be. Right. We have seen media scandals. So yes, theres absolute social signaling where were in a competition and I see it more on the right. But Im not sure other people would vote for a gay guy. Well. Both revolutions were caused, in one way or another, by taxes. And in fact, the dominion voting system that was the subject of an enormous amount of controversy, is a dramatic improvement over prior forms of voting. Back across the Atlantic Ocean, the people of the French colony of Saint Domingue (now Haiti) on the island of Hispaniola were watching the French Revolution very closely. Beginning with the Stamp Act of 1765, Great Britain tried and failed to raise revenue from their subjects in the American colonies. Absolutely. The American Revolution main aim was to gain independence from the British while the French revolutions main aim was to get rid of the French monarchy that was deemed corrupt. So all of the major social, political, cultural religious forces are pushing us apart into separate camps. This election had so many loopholes and so many places where you could achieve, you will never find what exactly. After twenty twenty two, where every one of the hypermagazine candidates in the statewide swing state election lost, every one of them. I thought that. But theyre not, like, mad about her. The French Revolution was not successful in forming a democratic government due to Frances history of a monarchy, economic issues and divison among its people. The similarity between them is that the citizens in both countries, both faced the block of common economical development of the government. Thats like, old stuff. The people there are kind and unprejudiced. Will see you guys again next week. Why? Several horses and men are down. These countries shared the same idea of freedom and independence, the difference is they used different methods of accomplishing this goal. As the ideas spread over the years American and French lives would change slowly. The American Revolution A revolution, in definition, is the overthrow of one government with replacement of another. No, its more secure. The American Revolution set the background for the modern nation state as well as molding the modern Army. Right? There always has been this sort of populist mainly white working class populist part of American politics, whatever it is, fifteen percent of America, twenty percent of America, and Trump tapped into that group pretty decisively. Were telling everybody dont trust mail in balloting. Itd be hard for everybody to find. It rejected European racist hierarchies and defined all Haitians as "black." Composed of seven states from the South, this new government looked to separate from a union that they felt was tipping in power towards those who wanted to threaten the rights of the South, especially slavery. people want to end up And so if you are watching right wing media, youre not gonna know. You know, the majority of people in Scotland voted to stay. you should take her seriously, but not literally. Im Sarah Longwell, Publisher of The Bulwark. They dont give. Now theres been some gradual lessening on the left as well, but mainly on the right. And if you listen to right wing media, if your entire diet is right wing media, youre going to hear wild things all the time, and it was reflected in what they just said about voting, for example. been a long time. They both got their idea from Enlightenment thinkers. Right? Theyre a lot more commonality than we believe. Direct link to layladuran.2007's post What factors led to the A, Posted 10 months ago. Kristen Soltis Anderson, I believe, And, Kristen, Im sorry, Im misattributing this to you, but I remember hearing an interview where youre talking about polling Republicans and how important the person at the top of the ticket is to Republican views on issue after issue after issue.